Reviewers at Vulture felt the episode was "sad and awkward" to watch, specifically criticizing Jenny's decision to steal as out of character for her normally "clever" self.

"Gossip Girl" The Blair Bitch Project (TV Episode 2008) - IMDb

noted it was a great horror show with some lighting issues that still managed to keep the audience unsettled.

Blair returns to school after losing her "Queen Bee" status, only to be mocked by her former clique. Meanwhile, Jenny steals a designer Valentino dress to fit in with the wealthy crowd, leading to a showdown at her 15th birthday party.