Users on community forums and retail sites have shared mixed but passionate experiences:
: The cookies are frequently praised for their "fun" look, featuring rainbow sprinkles embedded in the creme and celebratory designs on the wafers. buy oreo birthday cake
“Solid. I wouldn't call it a rockstar, but it's very respectable. It reminds me of an original Oreo mixed with some of those frosted animal crackers.” chiefeats.food.blog · 7 years ago Buying Information Users on community forums and retail sites have
The Oreo Birthday Cake Chocolate Sandwich Cookies Go to product viewer dialog for this item. It reminds me of an original Oreo mixed
: A common critique is that they are "unbalanced" or "sickeningly sweet" compared to standard Oreos. Purists may find the cake flavor too intense for more than one or two cookies. Consumer Feedback
“This birthday cake flavor has a strong smell to the cookie, almost like a strong frosting smell. The frosting has a sprinkle type inside of it.” Dollar General
: Reviewers from The Kitchn note the creme tastes "eerily similar" to store-bought confetti frosting. Some users find the chocolate cookie helps balance the "artificial" cake notes, though it can leave a slightly bitter aftertaste for some.