The episode received a polarized response from the community on platforms like IMDb and Letterboxd :
: Enthusiasts on Reddit pointed out discrepancies between the show's claims and other documentaries (like Netflix's Crime Scene ), particularly regarding elevator floor numbers and the state of the water tank lid. [S22E0] Cecil Hotel
: Skeptics were notably impressed by medium Patti Negri, who, uncoached, immediately targeted specific rooms tied to tragic history, including room 1431 (a 1938 suicide) and room 1016 (the "Pigeon Goldie" Osgood murder). The episode received a polarized response from the
: During an attempt to contact the spirit of serial killer Jack Unterweger, a spirit box response clearly said “Your mom” twice—a moment described as both bizarre and oddly fitting for a killer known for mocking authority. [S22E0] Cecil Hotel