Fans often cite this as one of the most pivotal episodes of Season 1 because it moves the Red John "over-arc" forward significantly. 🎠Cast Highlights
The dying message "HE IS MAR" sparked years of fan theories. Was it a name? A location? A partial word?
Renfrew plays on Jane's desperation, while Jane, in turn, manipulates the CBI and the legal system.
Jane discovers evidence—a "Red John" smiley face in a hidden location—that suggests Renfrew was indeed connected to the killer.

The_mentalist_1x11_gli_amici_di_john_il_rosso_b... Apr 2026
Fans often cite this as one of the most pivotal episodes of Season 1 because it moves the Red John "over-arc" forward significantly. 🎠Cast Highlights
The dying message "HE IS MAR" sparked years of fan theories. Was it a name? A location? A partial word? The_Mentalist_1x11_Gli_amici_Di_John_Il_Rosso_b...
Renfrew plays on Jane's desperation, while Jane, in turn, manipulates the CBI and the legal system. Fans often cite this as one of the
Jane discovers evidence—a "Red John" smiley face in a hidden location—that suggests Renfrew was indeed connected to the killer. The_Mentalist_1x11_Gli_amici_Di_John_Il_Rosso_b...