: Some viewers find the documentary deeply heart-breaking and powerful, while others have criticized it for feeling "exploitative".
Critically, the film is noted for its unfiltered—and at times controversial—approach to documenting its subjects:
More like this * 9.1. Take My Breath. Watchlist. * 4.4. One Day Like Rain. Watch options. * 4.3. The Daughter. Watch options. Upon the Shadow (2017) - Letterboxd
: The use of re-enacted scenes has led some to feel certain moments are "fake" or "strange," though many acknowledge the central story remains essential. Upon the Shadow (2017)
: There are scenes where subjects state they do not want to be filmed, raising ethical questions about the director’s "fascination" with their vulnerability.